Can You Solve the Mystery of the Invoice Errors?

30th October 2020

It’s no secret that card processing arrangements are complex and opaque. So, it won’t surprise you that CMSPI analysis has revealed that many merchants in the U.S. are being consistently overcharged, often by millions of dollars every year. We’ve helped some of the largest merchants in the world conduct invoice audits and the results have been alarming – often finding seven-figure overcharges.

1 in 2 of our audits uncover material errors and some merchants are particularly vulnerable depending on the nature of their payments mix and the players in their individual payments supply chain.

Often, merchants are able to reconcile their arrangements by comparing their processing invoices to their contracts, however, this approach will only uncover certain error-types. A merchant is unable to gain visibility beyond the information provided by the payments supply chain.

We see misapplied fees on a daily basis under various guises – and, in honor of Halloween season, and to raise awareness of Phantom Fees, we’ve created CMSPI’s very own ‘whodunnit’ board game, where you and your colleagues can play detective and identify where the merchant has been mischarged.

Want to solve the mystery? Download a printable version of the game pieces and instructions here.

The Suspects

The Weapons

Keying Errors
There are thousands of different possible charges that you might see on your invoices, and these are changing constantly. This doesn’t just mean that keying errors are possible: it means they’re actually likely.

Misapplied Rates
The varying rates applied to your transactions may be incorrect, as different payment types, channels and transaction values will incur different fees. With many charges being hidden in complex management information and opaque reporting data, having true visibility into whether these various rates are being charged correctly is extremely difficult with just monthly invoices.

Non-standard Transactions
Transactions that don’t fit into a distinct charging category can often incur excessive fees and, due to the complexity of the thousands of possible rates, these too often go unnoticed by merchants.

Pass-through Fees
Charges that card processors pass on to merchants from the card networks can often contain hidden premiums. These pass-through costs are extremely complex, including factors such as exchange rate fluctuations; settlement timescale differences; and variations in pricing structures.

Phantom Fees
Because your payments profile is inherently complex, your invoice breakdown will be just as complex. Different transactions will incur different fee types – leaving room for phantom fees to go unnoticed.

Although it may seem unlikely to constitute a significant cost, rounding up fractional fees can result in a substantial overcharge – particularly for merchants processing large volumes of card transactions.

Umbrella Charges
In some instance, smaller fees may be blended together on your invoice under an “umbrella charge”. Merging these fees together ultimately allows for a premium to be added to the headline rate, so it’s essential that you understand the individual components of these charges.

All of these complexities make it impossible for merchants to thoroughly audit their merchant service charge. Without the necessary information, internal resource and knowledge to navigate through that information, and without the industry insight needed to accurately benchmark what fees should be applied to what transaction, many merchants will be overpaying by substantial six and seven-figure sums every year.

These overcharges aren’t necessarily lost – conducting a thorough historical invoice audit could mean large reclaims are possible. In a payments landscape where fees are ever-increasing, the payments mix is shifting quickly, and merchants face an unprecedented external challenge, merchants can’t afford to assume their invoices are error-free – start your audit today.

There are over 700 possible fees and charges that can appear on a merchant's MSC invoice. These can sometimes be hidden or blended together, making it very difficult to spot. These fees are complex, and it’s easy to see how even one of the seven reasons listed above could be negatively impacting your bottom-line.

Jake Danby, CMSPI Business Development

You Might Also Be Interested In These...

Former CEO of Deloitte Consulting Joins CMSPI as Chairman of the Board

CMSPI announced the appointment of industry leader John Kerr as chairman of its board of directors.

Read More >
The 6 Biggest Takeaways from the Federal Reserve Regulation ii Report

The 6 biggest takeaways from the Federal Reserve Regulation ii Report – CMSPI Insights

Read More >
What Does the Fed Report Say About Fraud?

This article will explore the differences in performance between global card networks and U.S. domestic card networks in each of these environments.

Read More >
What Is Debit Routing? A CMSPI Insights Infographic

CMSPI’s infographic on debit routing explains the uses and benefits of debit card routing to merchants and consumers.

Read More >
Arrange an audit of your payment invoices