The Restaurant Payments Opportunity: From Cost to Competitive Advantage
Restaurants face mounting payments complexity and margin pressure. Discover six critical challenges and how CMSPI helps global brands uncover significant savings and optimize performance across evolving digital and delivery ecosystems.
Quick-service and dine-in restaurants are navigating an increasingly complex payments landscape, as rising digital volumes, expanding delivery models, and fragmented technology ecosystems put pressure on already-thin margins. CMSPI works with 30% of U.S. QSRs, as well as leading QSR and dining brands internationally, helping merchants identify and deliver hundreds of millions of dollars in annual payments savings. Ahead of CMSPI’s upcoming webinar on the topic, we’ll break down six of the most pressing payments challenges facing restaurant merchants today, along with the opportunities available to those willing to look closer.
A Hyper Complex Payments Environment
Restaurant merchants now support a growing number of payment journeys – counter, kiosk, pay-at-table (think QR scan), waiter-assisted, app, online ordering, and click-and-collect – and each typically runs on its own point-of-sale infrastructure and payments partner. This fragmentation results in multiple contracts, SLAs, and commercial constructs, limiting merchants’ ability to leverage their full transaction volume in negotiations. It also creates friction in identifying customers, standardizing customer experience, and reconciling payouts across channels. This is only compounded given each payment supply chain partner has varying levels of capacity across products, payment channels, and technologies.
Digital ordering, the channel most restaurant brands are prioritizing to build loyalty and repeat visits, typically carries a higher cost of acceptance than in-store transactions due to higher interchange and network fee exposure. As digital volume grows, it can cannibalize lower-cost in-store spend even as overall sales increase, meaning growth in the merchant’s preferred channel does not automatically translate into proportional margin growth.
Card Fees: Complex, Growing, & Disproportionate
Restaurant transactions typically range from $10 to $70, well below the average ticket size of large-format retailers, making fixed, per-transaction fees and pass-through costs disproportionately impactful. Inflation and rising percentage-based pricing on network and interchange fees have compounded this pressure on already-thin margins.
CMSPI’s work across QSR and casual dining brands has also identified a shift from debit to credit card spend, a trend consistent with broader consumer behavior in retail and other sectors. Because credit acceptance costs more than debit, this shift adds a further structural driver of rising acceptance costs, independent of any single merchant’s operations.
Transactions in this sector are subject to immense downgrades due to the involvement of so many partners and lapses in data harmonization These punishments can take the form in higher pass through fees to merchants as wells as impacting approvals for customer initiated transaction. Auditing across payment experiences is paramount for this vertical to discover undue pass through and leakages.
PINless Routing and Supply Chain Readiness
Many restaurant brands process debit volumes large enough to support meaningful network negotiating leverage through PINless routing. However, point-of-sale and processor infrastructure is not always configured to enable it. Historical throughput considerations in fast food, where checkout speed at the counter has long been prioritized, have also limited investment in debit strategy more broadly.
Both Card Present and Card Not Present saw over 17% of BINs shift available networks, combine that with Card Present PINless sitting between 50 and 60%, restaurants face near constant and evolving pressure to properly identify BINs and advocate to regulators to get enablement up to the regulated 100% threshold.
Without clear visibility into routing optionality, it is difficult for merchants to calculate the full value of a PINless strategy, or to prioritize it relative to other technology investments. Aligning technology, procurement, and payments strategy is a prerequisite for capturing this opportunity.
POS and Technology Strategy
All-in-one platforms bundling point-of-sale hardware, ecommerce, and payments processing into a single contract have grown more prevalent across the sector. These arrangements can reduce the operational burden of a fragmented technology estate.
The tradeoff is reduced visibility into the underlying cost of acceptance, as bundled pricing can obscure where a vendor’s margin sits and where costs may be negotiable. CMSPI’s analysis of these arrangements across the sector has found that premiums on card acceptance costs are frequently embedded within all-in-one contracts. This raises a central question for restaurant technology leaders: whether current infrastructure is fit for purpose over the next three to five years, and whether it is being secured at the right price.
Franchisee and Payment Facilitator Complexity
For franchised restaurant brands, each location can effectively represent its own payments estate, with distinct processor relationships, pricing, and commercial terms. This creates challenges for corporate payment teams seeking to standardize reconciliation, reporting, and payout structures while preserving flexibility for franchisees with limited payments expertise.
Payment facilitators and similar all-in models have gained popularity in this segment in part because they simplify onboarding, reporting, and support for franchisees. Balancing centralized control with franchisee flexibility, particularly across onboarding, cash flow, and settlement, remains an ongoing challenge for corporate payments and treasury teams.
Often-Ignored Opportunities
Beyond core payment acceptance costs, CMSPI’s work with restaurant merchants has identified further opportunities in authorization optimization, retry logic, and chargeback management. Dynamic Currency Conversion (DCC) is a further example: although international transactions typically represent a small share of restaurant merchants’ overall volume, our data indicates that DCC can generate meaningful savings and additional negotiating leverage, even in checkout environments where speed is a critical priority.
Looking Ahead
As digital adoption, delivery models, and technology partnerships continue to reshape the restaurant payments landscape, merchants that invest in granular data analysis are better positioned to identify where costs and opportunities are hiding across their payments estate. Top of mind for QSR and restaurant brands for immediate relief should focus on auditing passthrough fees, investing in technology that allows for optimal routing, and continuing to seek transparency in your transaction data. These themes, along with further data and perspectives from payments leaders at leading QSR brands, will be explored in CMSPI’s upcoming webinar.